Promotions are a key part of employee development, but timing and approach matter. This checklist helps you evaluate when an employee is ready for promotion, followed by detailed guidance on how to execute the promotion process effectively.
For more information on this topic, check out our blog post, How to Evaluate if an Employee is Ready for a Promotion.
1. Consistently High Performance
• Has the employee consistently delivered excellent work?
• Do they regularly meet or exceed expectations?
• Have they mastered their current responsibilities?
2. Leadership Potential
• Has the employee demonstrated leadership qualities, even if they’re not in a formal leadership role?
• Do they mentor peers, take initiative on projects, or make strong decisions?
• Can they inspire and guide others?
3. Growth and Adaptability
• Is the employee continuously developing their skills?
• Do they proactively seek feedback and adapt to new challenges?
• Have they shown improvement in areas critical for their next role?
4. Cultural Fit and Values Alignment
• Does the employee embody the company’s values?
• Do they contribute positively to the workplace culture?
Before offering a promotion, it’s important to evaluate whether the employee has exhibited all of the factors for a promotion while also minimizing any gaps in the skills required for the new role. Addressing these gaps through training, mentorship, or coaching helps ensure a smooth transition and sets them up for success.
Transparency is key during a promotion. Clearly communicate the new responsibilities and expectations for the role, and ensure that the employee understands the goals they’ll be measured against.
Once promoted, employees need ongoing support. Offering leadership training, access to mentors, or shadowing opportunities can help the employee thrive in their new role and manage the increased responsibilities.
Recognition is an important part of the promotion process. Announce the promotion publicly, highlight the employee’s contributions, and celebrate their new role to inspire others and reinforce the value of growth within your company.
Sometimes, even top-performing employees may not be ready for a promotion. Be cautious if:
The employee may need further training to handle the new responsibilities effectively. In these cases, focus on development rather than immediate promotion.
Not everyone wants to take on a leadership role. If the employee is hesitant or uninterested in new responsibilities, have a conversation about their career goals before moving forward.
If the employee’s performance has been inconsistent or they haven’t demonstrated the reliability needed for the next role, it may be best to address these issues before offering a promotion.
Promotions should be part of a larger strategy for career development. Here’s how to ensure your company has a clear, transparent path for advancement:
Work with employees to outline the skills and experiences needed for promotion. Regularly review and update these plans to reflect their progress and goals.
Regular check-ins help employees stay on track toward their goals. Offering constructive feedback ensures they know where they stand and what they need to work on.
Foster a culture where employees feel comfortable expressing interest in new roles and asking for development opportunities. This ensures that promotions are aligned with their aspirations.
Promotions, when done thoughtfully, set employees up for long-term success and contribute to the overall growth of the company. Use this approach to ensure promotions are earned, well-supported, and aligned with both individual and organizational goals.
Collect feedback for your team seamlessly with WorkStory
