Software Engineering

Should You Share Performance Evaluation Results with Employees?

The fundamental issue with the question of whether to share or not share performance evaluation results lies in the element of surprise.
Published on
May 2024

Q: Should We Share the Results of Our 9-Box Exercise with Our Employees?

A: The most "successful" teams do, in fact, share the results with their team members. However, what's more important is that feedback on performance is shared throughout the year, not just during the completion of performance evaluations.

The Importance of Continuous Feedback

Sharing feedback consistently keeps managers and employees aligned, ensuring that everyone knows what needs to be focused on at all times.

This approach prevents any surprises when the conclusions of the 9-box exercise or any other performance evaluations are finally shared.

The fundamental issue with the question of whether to share or not share performance evaluation results lies in the element of surprise.

The Dangers of Surprise Feedback

It’s detrimental to have a low-performing employee who is unaware of their performance issues until it's too late. This scenario is problematic for several reasons:

  • Lost Development Time: From a management perspective, not addressing performance issues promptly results in lost time that could have been used to help the employee develop.
  • Employee Demotivation: As an employee, being blindsided by negative feedback is hugely demotivating. They're left feeling worst than when they went into the conversation—potentially a big hit to productivity.
  • Team Turnover: Demotivation and disengagement often leads to departures from the organization. Turnover is hugely costly to the organization and can be minimized with the right approach.

Benefits of Sharing Performance Evaluation Results

Encourages Continuous Improvement

Regularly sharing performance evaluation results fosters a culture of continuous improvement.

Employees are more likely to take ownership of their development when they receive ongoing feedback, leading to more proactive efforts to improve their performance.

Enhances Employee Engagement

Transparency in performance evaluations boosts employee engagement.

When employees understand how they are being assessed and where they stand (and what they can aim for) they feel more connected to their roles and motivated to excel.

Builds Trust and Transparency

Open communication about performance builds trust between employees and management. Trust is essential for a healthy workplace culture and can significantly improve team dynamics.

Aligns Organizational Goals

Sharing performance evaluation results helps align individual performance with organizational goals. Employees who understand their contributions to the bigger picture are more likely to work towards common objectives, fostering a sense of unity and purpose within the team.

Best Practices for Sharing Performance Evaluation Results

Share Feedback Regularly

Do not wait for formal performance evaluations to share feedback. Regular, informal check-ins can provide timely insights and guidance, helping employees stay on track and feel supported in their development.

Be Constructive and Supportive

When sharing performance evaluation results, focus on constructive feedback that highlights areas for improvement while also acknowledging strengths.

Offer support and resources to help employees address any performance gaps.

Create a Safe Feedback Environment

Encourage an open and safe environment for feedback. Employees should feel comfortable discussing their performance without fear of negative consequences.

This approach fosters honest communication and a willingness to improve.

Use Clear and Objective Criteria

Ensure that performance evaluations are based on clear and objective criteria. Use the SMART framework if needed when establishing future development goals.

This transparency helps employees understand the basis of their assessments and reduces the likelihood of misunderstandings or perceived biases.

Embracing a Culture of Feedback

Ultimately, the question of whether to share performance evaluation results is part of a broader discussion about fostering a culture of feedback within the organization. In regularly sharing performance evaluation results, organizations can enhance employee engagement, build trust, and drive continuous improvement.

By integrating transparency, specifically, into your performance evaluation processes, you create a more aligned workforce. Sharing results constructively and frequently is not just beneficial—it’s essential for the growth and success of both employees and the organization as a whole.

Weekly newsletter
Join hundreds of HR and team leads—receive our very best resources in your inbox every week.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Whenever you’re ready, here are 4 ways WorkStory can help you:

  1. The WorkStory Platform: Our all-in-one performance management solution. WorkStory makes it easy to gather continuous feedback, run 360 reviews, and track team progress—all in one place. Perfect for teams looking to move beyond traditional performance reviews.
  2. The Performance Review Builder Tool: Create customized performance reviews that fit your organization’s unique needs. Tailor the reviews to each role, streamline the review process, and focus on growth-oriented feedback.
  3. Performance Review Templates: Access a library of pre-built, best-in-class performance review templates that are ready to use. Whether you need templates for leadership, team members, or cross-functional roles, we’ve got you covered.
  4. HR Document Templates: From onboarding checklists to change management guides, our HR templates are designed to save time and ensure consistency across your organization. Simply download, customize, and implement.
Latest Posts
Newsletter

How to Hold Managers Accountable for Performance Reviews

The truth is, performance reviews don’t fail because of employees—they fail because managers aren’t being held accountable for their role in the process. Here’s why manager accountability matters and how you can make it a priority in your organization.
Read post
Newsletter

Three Common Performance Review Pitfalls—and How to Avoid Them

As we head into the end-of-year review season, it’s a good time to evaluate how you’re conducting performance reviews. A well-executed review process can inspire and set a clear path for growth. But a few common pitfalls can turn reviews into an ineffective or even dreaded experience for employees.
Read post
Newsletter

5 Signs Your Team Is Quiet Quitting (And How to Fix It)

As a leader, one of the most challenging things to spot is when your team members have mentally checked out but are still physically present. This phenomenon is called quiet quitting—where employees do the bare minimum without showing the engagement they once had.
Read post