Software Engineering

Getting Ready for Annual Reviews: A Guide to Preparing for Effective Performance Evaluations

The time for annual performance reviews is rolling around once more. As a manager, thoughtfully conducted reviews allow you to provide meaningful feedback, set aligned goals, identify growth opportunities, and guide your team’s development over the past year.
Published on
March 2024

The time for annual performance reviews is rolling around once more. As a manager, thoughtfully conducted reviews allow you to provide meaningful feedback, set aligned goals, identify growth opportunities, and guide your team’s development over the past year.

But first, proper planning and preparation are key to enabling productive conversations.

Follow these best practices to get fully ready for annual review season...

Schedule Meetings Well in Advance and Set Expectations

Don’t let review deadlines creep up unexpectedly - get them booked early. Schedule all one-on-one meetings at least 2-3 months in advance to give employees plenty of notice to prepare.

Block off 30-60 minutes for each review conversation on your calendar.

Once scheduled, send reminders about the reviews along with any forms or self-assessment templates (if you're not using WorkStory). This gives employees a chance to reflect and gather their thoughts before the meeting.

Clearly communicate your expectations for any self-evaluations and provide guiding questions to prompt meaningful analysis of their own performance and growth throughout the year.

If you find preparing review paperwork and templates to be a hassle, WorkStory's automated system avoids the need for cumbersome forms and assessments. Everything is handled seamlessly on one centralized platform.

For managers, create a master calendar to track all upcoming review deadlines, meetings, and follow-ups in one organized place. Calendar invites can help lock in schedules across the team.

When you plan thoughtfully from the start, you set yourself and employees up for an impactful review process.

Reflect on Progress Toward Past Goals

Don’t conduct reviews in a silo - connect them to employees' wider growth journeys.

Pull up last year’s finalized reviews to revisit previous goals, achievements, and developmental areas. Note the key progress made so far and what skills still need focus.

These insights pave the way for more meaningful conversations around development - which is the real reason for doing performance reviews in the first place.

Then collaboratively set aligned SMART goals for the upcoming review period - targets that ladder up to wider team and organizational objectives. Employees should leave understanding how their goals connect to the bigger picture.

Regular Check-Ins

Ideally, you would be conducting regular check-ins throughout the year to discuss performance, goals, and to identify targets for growth.

In doing so, you're creating a record of individual performance which will set you up for success in the larger annual performance reviews.

A positive side-effect of holding check-ins or 1:1s is that the team member will never be surprised by the performance review. If your employees are walking into the conversation without a complete understanding of how well they've been performing, you're setting yourself up for failure and ultimately for an uncomfortable conversation which may leave the employee demotivated and less engaged in the longer term.

Gather Insights from Key Players

Reviews become more robust when you solicit insights from different perspectives. Reach out to colleagues and team members who regularly interact with the employee to gather feedback.

Ask for specific examples and metrics that paint a detailed picture of performance beyond general impressions. The richer the insights, the more effective the review.

It's hard to collect these insights throughout the year - rather than once a year - but that's where WorkStory shines. See how we capture performance data continuously.

In your notes, compile any relevant performance data like sales figures, satisfaction scores, productivity stats.

Hard metrics often surface progress and problems more objectively - they tell an important story on their own.

Also document any performance issues that need to be addressed - the developmental areas along with the wins. Well-rounded reviews provide growth-oriented feedback, not just praise.

Determine the Best Review Format

Decide whether you want to use standard forms or a more conversational format centered around open-ended questions. Just remain consistent across the team.

Evaluate how technology like automated performance management systems can bolster and streamline the process.

Carefully structure the dialogue to cover wins, strengths, improvements, career aspirations and future goals. Prepare talking points and performance examples you want to be sure to cover.

The best reviews are interactive, future-focused, and never a surprise to the team member.

Don't Just Check the Box

With proper upfront planning and preparation, you can conduct more meaningful, effective reviews directly tied to company objectives and employee growth.

If spreadsheets make your current process cumbersome, consider a streamlined platform like WorkStory that avoids the need for forms and templates.

Invest time now to thoughtfully set up both managers and employees for review success down the line.

Weekly newsletter
Join hundreds of HR and team leads—receive our very best resources in your inbox every week.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Whenever you’re ready, here are 4 ways WorkStory can help you:

  1. The WorkStory Platform: Our all-in-one performance management solution. WorkStory makes it easy to gather continuous feedback, run 360 reviews, and track team progress—all in one place. Perfect for teams looking to move beyond traditional performance reviews.
  2. The Performance Review Builder Tool: Create customized performance reviews that fit your organization’s unique needs. Tailor the reviews to each role, streamline the review process, and focus on growth-oriented feedback.
  3. Performance Review Templates: Access a library of pre-built, best-in-class performance review templates that are ready to use. Whether you need templates for leadership, team members, or cross-functional roles, we’ve got you covered.
  4. HR Document Templates: From onboarding checklists to change management guides, our HR templates are designed to save time and ensure consistency across your organization. Simply download, customize, and implement.
Latest Posts
Newsletter

Gen Z Leaders Are Rising: How to Prepare Your Organization for the Shift

By 2025, 1 in 10 managers will be Gen Z. This generational shift marks a significant transformation in workplace leadership. Gen Z is stepping into management earlier than many expected, bringing new perspectives, priorities, and challenges.
Read post
Newsletter

How to Hold Managers Accountable for Performance Reviews

The truth is, performance reviews don’t fail because of employees—they fail because managers aren’t being held accountable for their role in the process. Here’s why manager accountability matters and how you can make it a priority in your organization.
Read post
Newsletter

Three Common Performance Review Pitfalls—and How to Avoid Them

As we head into the end-of-year review season, it’s a good time to evaluate how you’re conducting performance reviews. A well-executed review process can inspire and set a clear path for growth. But a few common pitfalls can turn reviews into an ineffective or even dreaded experience for employees.
Read post